Heiken Ashi values don't match MT4 values

[rickial]

I've attached 3 images...

1. The settings i used in FX Dreema
2. The comparision between MT4 heiken Ashi Open and FX Dreema Open for candle 1
3. The comparision between MT4 heiken Ashi Open and FX Dreema Open for candle 2

I've tested several versions of the idicator on MT4 and always get the same values for the open. An there is always a descrepency between FX dreema output and the MT indicator .

You have an awesome product and I have been using it for years. This is the first time I've found anything like this. I acknowledge that if might be something I'm doing wrong, and to be honest, I hope it is.

Cheers
Rick

[jstap]

@rickial Is this just because you are not selecting a candle type? FX uses the MT indicator so should be identical.

[rickial]

I've tried that and it doesn't seem to make any difference.

[jstap]

@rickial Put a shared link on here so your project can be assessed.

[rickial]

Thanks - shared/XgpFgqxzb

[jstap]

@rickial All is working as should, are you sure your not confusing the candle numbers?

[rickial]

I've looked over it, but I don't think that is the problem, although you have inadvertently solved another problem I was having with the code

If you look at the first example image, you can see that the FXdreema output for the open of candle one is 1.36354. On the chart I've drawn a red line at that level and it lines up with the high, not with the open. The FXdreema output for the high is also 1.36354. Even without referring to the MT4 output, the chart shows that the FXdreema output for the open and the open on the bar don't match.

Just confirm my understanding of the candle numbering, the current candle is candle 0 and the previous candle is candle 1 ?

[rickial]

In the example you've sent, candle 2 has the open and the high as exactly the same, but that is not the case. Candle 2 has a wick above the open, therefore the open and the high can't be the same. I'm talking about the open and high of the HA bars, not the normal candles, perhaps that is where there is some confusion.

[rickial]

Is there any progress on this?

[rickial]

Any Chance of a reply please?

[jstap]

@rickial Sorry mate but as you have said values don't match the reality, I have no way of changing these.

[rickial]

thanks for trying - appreciate your effort.