fxDreema

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Back to the main page
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Search

    Potential Disaster with ECN brokers!

    Questions & Answers
    1
    1
    1713
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • fxDreema
      fxDreema last edited by

      This is real situation from this morning. It happened to a friend of mine with AVA broker. I changed the name of the EA in the log:

      08:13:17 EANAME EURUSD,M30: Error occured. Error code 129
      08:13:19 EANAME EURUSD,M30: Error occured. Error code 129
      08:13:21 EANAME EURUSD,M30: invalid slippage for OrderSend function
      08:13:21 EANAME EURUSD,M30: invalid slippage for OrderSend function
      08:13:21 EANAME EURUSD,M30: Error occured. Error code 4051
      08:13:23 EANAME EURUSD,M30: invalid slippage for OrderSend function
      08:13:23 EANAME EURUSD,M30: invalid slippage for OrderSend function
      08:13:23 EANAME EURUSD,M30: Error occured. Error code 4051
      08:13:27 EANAME EURUSD,M30: open #10365265 sell 0.30 EURUSD at 1.30140 ok
      08:13:29 EANAME EURUSD,M30: Error occured. Error code 136
      
      

      Weird errors. This is ECN broker, so first the trade must be sent, and then stops to be modified. Everything happens in 2 steps - OrderSend() and then OrderModify(). The actual problem here is not that the trade has troubles to be opened, but after that - when stops must be placed. You can see that error 136, which means... "Off quotes".

      Leaving a trade without stops can be very dangerous sometimes, even if the EA itself is not scalping. For this EA - missing stops caused more trades to be opened because of wrong part in the code.

      For example, in non-ECN brokers there are 2 outcomes - to create a trade with stops or to not create a trade at all. With ECN broker you can be easily found in a situation with a trade with missing stops.

      So, be careful with ECN brokers. I know that everyone say that ECN is better, but obviously this is not exactly like that. It looks that every ECN broker has at least one more chance to fail - in OrderModify().

      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • 1 / 1
      • First post
        Last post

      Online Users

      J
      H
      E

      8
      Online

      146.7k
      Users

      22.4k
      Topics

      122.6k
      Posts

      Powered by NodeBB Forums | Contributors