Position closed block not working correctly.

[OntradingX]

Position closed block not working correctly.

I'm just trying to detect if the order was closed by Stop-Loss and I noticed that the block is not passing on this information.
@fxDreema can you check this?

Project Below:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/s77Ekci2b

[jstap]

You have this as specified, but you have not specified a symbol.

[OntradingX]

@jstap This shouldn't matter, I've always used it this way, even so I believe it's a defect in the block, I see a lot of posts from people complaining about the same problem, I'm only using it in one symbol and that's what the block should do, or am I wrong ?

[jstap]

So try it on any, (is what I use and previously it has stopped my blocks working). Also, I am on this forum more than anyone, and this is not a common problem

[mariussun]

It's common now, as for few days with the new MT5 build, there are some issues on Position Closed blocks. Works in previous builds but not properly in the latest and nobody seems to care..:(.
Even for some cases the block works but for more complex experts it's not getting the right signal for OnTrade area.

[jstap]

Yes, the new build has changed a few things, but the only way of knowing if that is the problem is to test other options also specified means to be specific. So without selecting something specific, it can't be.

[OntradingX]

@mariussun MT4 work fine, but MT5 no. I will try other methods to solve and wait @fxDreema verify this.

[mariussun]

@OntradingX any solution found?..:)

[OntradingX]

@mariussun Unfortunately, I'm encountering many problems even in ONCHART too and most of them didn't exist before, even in mt4 it happens too. I would like the administrator to be more attentive, because we pay for the service and we deserve to have a minimum of attention, as the days are deducted from our plans, but we were unable to move forward due to the lack of correction.

[rajeshkumarvga]

"Position Closed" block is not working properly on MT5 build 22 Jan 24 (build 4153).
Any workaround, please?

[l'andorrà]

@rajeshkumarvga I replied to that same question on another thread. Please don't duplicate them on many threads.

[s00071609]

Looks like none of the OnTrade blocks work correctly. In my case specified symbol vs All symbol don't work correctly. For example, If position opened block is used for BTCUSD and there are existing positions for XAUUSD, the block runs for both. It should only be picking BTCUSD. Definately a bug and a bad one as it cannot identify symbol and which trade it relates to.