Hi,
thx for your reply.
you mean orange one above which is connected to the buy/ sell row?
You mean the TradeCountBS Variable.
for reset block it is at 0 isnt it?
Have disconnected tree below as sperate tree.
You would mean like following right?
https://fxdreema.com/shared/alAvT6Trb
Hi guys,
does somebody know a simple way or default indicator to filter tight consolidation, or consolidation phases in general for heiken ashi for EA?
Similar to ADX, ATR or Bollinger Bands.
Thank you in advance.
contraction or extension. So low Volatility and phases of increased Volatility.
Mainly that when market is tight near MA it tends to move away from Moving Average and when it is far away it then pulls back.
Often breakout appears from low/ narrow Moving Average state.
But found that Moving average often is very subjective, because market often fluctuates above and below, sort of like area.
System flows like Bollinger Bands, when bands contract and expand.
Stop using them because gave me to many false signals when momentum continues.
Also found that simply using flat bands and angled bands doesnt work that good, because often it lags due to market flattening or breakout.
Found that ADX would give to many and late entry with value system above 20 or 25.
ATR is good to determine Stop Level, but often when ATR is high, curve still tends to decreases as well afterwards even if Volatility keeps increasing.
Also doesnt want to use any form of "oversold overbought" indicator
even if only using the middle line/ 50 level,
like if it breaks above or below, because found from backtesting, that in consolidation phase, it flucates often, for 2 period or longer period like 14 for example.
Ok, so i simply need add both High and Low as variables?
Do you mean like using the regular opposite candles as trigger right?
For example HA was bullish but actual candle was already bearish.
Found from testing that using the opposite candle type for trigger candle that this often fails when market still continues trend.
Hi,
thank you.
so you suggest using conditions block instead right?
For example, buy signal Heiken Ashi, Bull Candle, Low, previous opposite
What would you suggest for using the is <> =?
Tried using Candle 0 > Candle 1 for buy for instance but got same breakout false signal, that bot jumps after price move, than rather using the better price below of the candle.
Also tried using candle heiken ashi candle type low wick but doesnt seem to open, because often in the moment when market retraces from the wick, then heiken ashi color changes.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/yT3OvQ09e
Hi,
how do i set daily trades limit?
Thank you in advance.
Would like to keep it fairly easy about 2 trades per day limit.
Currently using EA for Prop Trading to calculate Lot size and Stop loss based on percent base of balance of 0.5%, but might increases to 1% during challenge.
Due to daily loss of 5% and max loss limit 10%,
i dont like idea to have max. 2 losses per day allowed, rather 2 trades in general.
Because e.g. if first trade was profitable bot might trade further until there are 2 losses.
Have tried suggestion of other user, this but bot still opens to many positions per day.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/19SeOjMFb
Hi,
Sorry forget to add the link for sharing.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/N3oVQHOhc
mr @l-andorrĂ recommended to use variables to give signal bit offset to appear.
Found from backtesting that Di crossing often appears first, then ADX rises about afterwards.
While ADX rises above, found that in same time Heiken Ashi forms to confirm the entry.
Testet each on by it self.
It works good but not in confluence.
Thats why i'm asking 
Yes, i've found most of the times there were some fakeouts at bollinger bands, but dont wanna mess with market when there is momentum.
Yes its like vwap, when bands are flat i always tried range trading, but often market only has paused to sometime to continue in trend direction.
Have burned to much many this way before actual change happended.
Found it is easier to just wait for the impulse move and go with momentum, whether market moving sideways or trend.
Hi,
noticed from backtesting that heiken ashi bot opens trades sometimes for both buy and sell at the same time.
Read on an old thread to just use 1 once per bar, but hasen't changed.
Somebody got any idea why.
Thank you
https://fxdreema.com/shared/1apsu2Hie
https://fxdreema.com/shared/s9SfYSNGd
Hi,
please, i need help with heiken ashi bot.
Thank you .
how can i enter for Heiken Ashi for buy on lowest point of the candle and for sell highest point of the candle?
Don't want bot to buy/sell at the breakout of candle , but this would cause bad risk reward.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/1apsu2Hie
Hi people,
need help for entry and trade management conditions.
Thank you in advance.
Would like to keep the bot as simple as possible, but framework should use the Heiken Ashi, because having good results for solo testing, but need to add some filter.
Currently building simple trend following/momentum based system using Heiken Ashi, ADX and Parabolic.
For Entry conditions,
Buy conditions , Di+ crosses -Di as a trigger. Then ADX should go above 20.
On Heiken Ashi Bullish Candle for lowest point, bot should buy.
Sell conditions , Di - crosses Di + as a trigger. Then ADX should go above 20.
On Heiken Ashi Bullish Candle for lowest point, bot should buy.
The system would work on its own but to prevent tight or ranging conditions using the ADX value as filter to enter by momentum.
Found that moving average would give false signals, because price fluctuates around normally, and would help that price must be above MA for entry because sometimes trigger appears earlier below.
For trade management looking for Heiken Ashi opposite candle, but to prevent little retracement but trade would still be valid using parabolic sar to indicate final closing of position.
For entry conditions using modify variable for adx because got the tip from earlier project that it must appear different time than other condition to be valid, but bot somestimes doesnt trigger at all.
Somebody got any idea why?
Nevermind, have changed strategy for heiken ashi.
Using simple Heiken Ashi and ADX system instead.
Still would like to use Heiken Ashi as Exit indication but found from backtesting that there a smaller continuation opposite candles for heiken ashi, therefore would like to confirm that trend is still active as second condition until heiken and the condition changes.
Found that Parabolic Sar would help pretty good with that.
Havent found success for bollinger bands, because in most cases it is just easier to follow the trend and not trade against it.
Please have a look a my latest post sir.
Thank you.
Hi, nice that it is working for you.
I've found from backtesting that momentum keeps on pushing it is easier to just go with the trend.
Haven't found success for reversal trading.
Have developed simple momentum strategy with heiken ashi.
What do you mean by decreasing in value, you mean the stochastic, like a divergence?
thank you anyway
Ok, have found that it is the easiest way for me to trade, can only recommend it.
Have you used Heiken Ashi system before?
Hi,
have come to the conclusion that bollinger bands would give to many falls signals when market is trending.
I really like the idea of bollinger bands and it looks good in hindsight.
Have removed this idea entirely.
Because most oven the times only thing to enter on Heiken Ashi is to identify if there is range or impulse/ momentum.
Found this way simpler
Still using Heiken Ashi but switched to simple ADX Crossing for Di and ADX Value.
Hi,
the idea is to check for 2 possible outcomes.
Whether price stops at the middle band and then heiken ashi changes, which would close the trade or if momentum continues through for opposite bollinger bands.
With the or block i wanted to make sure it should look for middle bollinger bands as first target for both.
Found from the backtesting that heiken ashi sometimes changes color even before middle band was touched.
Can you please check if logic of the trade mgnt would be correct this way like explained to manage by heiken ashi for middle and other bollinger band?
thank you