Hi,
tested it solo for Bollinger bands trigger today with static take profit.
Unfortunately found that bot still misses lots of signals that would have been triggered.
Using the <= for buy and >= for sell, to catch both signals either if touched or market crosses above/below.
Also did backtest to give vertical line when triggered, blue for buy and magenat for sell, but still missed signals.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/9KFU51kZ
Yes, you're right.
Found in backtesting that Di crossing was super lagging. Unfortunately, because liked the simplicity of the indicator. 
Hi,
currently testing different approaches but need for closing position.
Thank you in advance
Using Heiken Ashi Candles and Bollinger Bands as main system components.
Main idea is to trade from upper deviation to lower and from lower to upper.
Would like to keep things very simple by 2 handles for condition block for "if trades" for open trades.
" And" "or"
This would be possible example:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/lnmISqkAb
What if found from testing when trade is open there are mainly 3 different outcomes possible:
price consolidates at middle band and it would be best to close position
price arrives at other Bollinger Bands, loss of momentum and then reverses so it would be best to close
price arrives at other Bollinger Bands but momentum continues shown by HA candles and then if Heiken Ashi switches color near band it would be best to close.
Simply, if momentum continues it should run,
if momentum stops or market starts consolidating it should stop.
Has somebody good results from ADX and DI crossing?
What i've found to just close it by opposite Heiken Ashi color would often cut trade way to early, in the "neutral Zone" between Bands and where Moving Average is.
Because there is only option in fxdreema to using Heiken Ashi but color and candle wick/type but not as heiken ashi dojis- loss of momentum/consolidation,
found that is would be best to have conjungtion with momentum as well to keep it simple.
I've testet common momentum indicator like RSI, Stochastic as well but found that that in ranging condition works good as extra confluence but if momentum keeps on going it market would continue way long at bands if heiken ashi color hasnt changed even if stochastic is oversold/overbought and or main line has crossed back below 80/20 Level.
Also testet approach to fixed Risk reward but due that every trade situation and outcome is different, found that simple 2:1/ 3:1 doesnt work, because sometimes market stops at middle band and sometimes want to continue even further.
Also found that every form of trailing stop would cut profit to early as well, because market is allowed to have wiggle room when expending and is even allowed for shorter retracements, because it is how markets tends to move.
Hi,
as i get it these are seperate trees or am i wrong?
You mean like 1 vertical row per indication right?
Yes sure
thank you for helping.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/Nd2vBD4ne
currently testing different exit strategies on the right.
I've changed the inputs for varibales and the flag settings for modify like you said.
Hi,
tried but unfortunately either only vertical lines are shown but not arrows, and if using only arrows, and also got the case that if arrows is shown, it is plotted on the candle not under for buy/ above for sell, like absolute value.
Also tried by following code to just look for the crossing for ADX Di and falling ADX as entry confirmation, but got the same results displayed.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/rh8eUJsxb
Hi,
testet today with your recommended settings for varibales, unfortunately EA doesnt trigger every signal found correct.
Hi, i got a similar question for line draw.
How can i draw arrow/ line for indicator below? thx
Hi guys,
currently testing EA with visual testing.
What i've found for indicators on chart like e.g. Bollinger bands it works by just connecting to "draw arrow" block,
but how can add visuals for indicators below chart like ADX for example?
When +DI crosses -DI from below would like to get an arrow printed.
Tested it this way but dont get correct arrow printed.
https://fxdreema.com/shared/JEtXQelPb
Also is it possible to get visual printing for both at current candle and the indicator itself, like dot printet at the lines for example?
Thank you
thank you sir,
so i need to place modify varibales under the Bollinger Bands conditions block, 1 each for Buy and Sell?
ok got it, just asking, you did mean the purple "varibales" one, not the constansts variables, orange right?
What i dont understand is, what do you place in for value?
Looked up for a tutorial on Youtube, but still dont understand,
because Bollinger bands there only period and deviation as number based.
How does it understand from 2 for example as value that it is the deviation?
or is the 0 just a " placeholder"?
Ok thank you very much, yes i understand, that it can be identifyed correct.
Really like Heiken Ashi mainly for trade mgnt until color shifts, it's like a trailing stop in itself.
Thank you,
Yes, for me, it's not about market strength, was looking more as confluence for Bollinger Bands and Heiken Ashi.
Found that Heiken Ashi filters a lot and simplifies system for market strength with bullish or bearish color.
Was trying different approach with opposite Candle but same Heiken Ashi as Entry signal.
e.g. Bullish Candle but Bearish Heiken Ashi at the Band and vise versa for buy.
But like other systems this works great in sideways conditions but not trend.
Could you please have a lot a the other thread due to this one for trade mgnt?
thank you a lot.
https://fxdreema.com/forum/topic/18835/close-position-by-heiken-ashi-2-different-outcomes
With Parabolic Sar was looking that dot appear at least 1 candle before the actual trigger candle appears.
Seems more congruent that oscillators like stochastic rsi when it's overbought/ oversold.
Found that when market is trending but for example overbought, market tends to continue.
Have you used parabolic Sar before or good experience with it?
Was testing tighter settings closer to the candle but unfortuantely doesnt seem to get it candles signal ahead but strangely sometimes dots appear earlier when highs/lows appears to be same height/ market didnt make higher high/ lower lows.
if you want to use Histogram as well, you can just use Oscillator of Moving Average.
It is pretty much the same like in macd.
The default one for macd in MT5 shows the "macd line" as a histogram,
Then you would have a components.
Re: Close Position by heiken Ashi 2 different outcomes
This would be additional question to added post from before.
Backtested Heiken Ashi in confluence with Bollinger Bands and Parabolic Sar,
for the trade mgnt situation.
Would like to make Parabolic Sar close to current price, currently testing other settings that default settings of 0.02/ 0.2 . Using 0.8 and 0.2 instead on 1h timeframe.
Moreover is it possible to get Parabolic signal 1 candle lookback, before actual reversal happens.
Found that sometimes Parabolic dots would give great entry confirmation because dots already below/above current candle, but sometimes dots appear later when trade setup already happended and Heiken Ashi and Bollinger BAnds would have given entry already.
Parabolic Sar should work as conjungtion for entry and trade mgnt.
Updated version of project:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/rFASsuw7c
Hi,
currently testing different approaches but need for closing position.
Thank you in advance
Using Heiken Ashi Candles and Bollinger Bands as main system components.
Main idea is to trade from upper deviation to lower and from lower to upper.
" And" "or"
This would be possible example:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/rXYiVwwnb
What if found from testing when trade is open there are mainly 3 different outcomes possible:
Simply, if momentum continues it should run,
if momentum stops or market starts consolidating it should stop.
What i've found to just close it by opposite Heiken Ashi color would often cut trade way to early, in the "neutral Zone" between Bands and where Moving Average is.
Because there is only option in fxdreema to using Heiken Ashi but color and candle wick/type but not as heiken ashi dojis- loss of momentum/consolidation,
found that is would be best to have conjungtion with momentum as well to keep it simple.
I've testet common momentum indicator like RSI, Stochastic as well but found that that in ranging condition works good as extra confluence but if momentum keeps on going it market would continue way long at bands if heiken ashi color hasnt changed even if stochastic is oversold/overbought and or main line has crossed back below 80/20 Level.
Also testet approach to fixed Risk reward but due that every trade situation and outcome is different, found that simple 2:1/ 3:1 doesnt work, because sometimes market stops at middle band and sometimes want to continue even further.
Also found that every form of trailing stop would cut profit to early as well, because market is allowed to have wiggle room when expending and is even allowed for shorter retracements, because it is how markets tends to move.
Yes, the idea is that Candle ID 1 < BB Low 2 for Buy and
Candle ID 1 > BB Up 2 for Sell as a trigger.
Then as a signal there is 2. condition block for confirmation.
Currently testing different approaches like Stochastics, Heiken Ashi for entry confirmation.
Found that Bearish Candle with Bullish Heiken Ashi works good as confirmation.
Bullish Candle with Bearish Heiken Ashi for Sell.
Stochastic signal seems sometimes a bit to early even though it crosses back.
Only is that when Heiken Ashi trigger candle appears it should work best when enter at highest point of the wick for sell and lowest point of the candle for buy like idea i was talking about earlier in this thread.
I've found different approaches for the candle type signal, which would you use in conjunction with HA? Does it need to be once per bar or continuous signal?
This is solo testing for candle type:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/DdWYQaS7e
This is current project:
https://fxdreema.com/shared/WaFV5krkd
Thank you in advance
Hi, thank you.
Ok so i should rather remove both set and check flag blocks and put them as variables/ constants inputs.
What do you mean for up and down trend, i mean bollinger bands only defines if prices are relatively high or low to its average right?
You mean something like classic Up trend -HH HL ?
How would you define this in Modify block?
Is it correct, modify block would just check if true like flag before right?
as values as inputs?
