Posts made by fifeivkbdedwcf

@l-andorrà

Is this the account of creator @fxDreema ?

So i would just place the trees next to each other like on the screenshot right?

For No Take Profit, fought because the middle row "for each position" has the HA Close Buy/ Sell as condition already.

As mentioned earlier it seems not to be working to just use Heiken Ashi Candle ID1 in Custom Price level in Buy/ Sell Block as TP.

As i get right, i need to add middle row to close by Heiken Ashi right?

Hi,

yes just like a daily loss and win filter to prevent overtrading.

with trees you just mean to connect something with the is true or false band right? orange and yellow.

Or do you mean to create an area?

With On trade you mean upper column next to on tick like on the screenshot?

If i got you right,

this whole rules needed to be placed under On Trade right or do i need to connect i again with the entry criteria?

https://fxdreema.com/shared/3ffL1Eape

Hi guys,

have checked previous threads about news filter.

Is there already a function in fx dreema to implement News filter from external website like tradedays for example?

Hi guys,

is there a way to implement a daily trade limit of max trades but with daily max loss and daily max win limit?
Furthermore i would it to use mainly 2 trades allowed per day but

Currently using 1% of account as Risk per Trade.

Because i'm also using trailing stop it dont have to be always exact 2* % win rate.

• if condition should be if at any trades it makes more than 1000$ per day it should stop

• if first trade was proftiable but under daily win limit it is allowed to take another trade

• if first trade was a minus, it is allowed to take another trade, if 2. trade was profitable it should stop, if 2. trade was unprofitable it should also stop.

Thx

@Ipod

Hi thanks for your answer.

is Roc like classic momentum indicator? testet it a bit, but seems to have lots of divergences as well.

Seems like Roc isnt available in fx dreema.

Speaking envelopes, tried both with classic envelopes and also thins like Bollinger Bands.

Thing with Bollinger Bands is, that yes with more volatility, the bands expand, and with lower volatility band come togehter, like the classic BB squeeze setup.

From testing i've found that most of the times, first comes the consolidation or range and then breakout, with the BB squeeze, when market breaks out the bands start to expand.
Dont really know how to inplement this is fx dreema.

Have you good success with Roc indicator, do you trade Trend following as well?

@l-andorrà

Thank you.

Yes have testet it as well with different candle ids like 1 for example.

Unfortunately trade then isnt closed for in chart indicators like Heiken Ashi for instance.

For ichimoku found that trade seems to react to candle id like you've mentioned.

Why doesnt it work with in chart for heiken ashi when it can be selected as take profit as well?
Have read your other thread and the heiken ashi approaches for trailing stop combo.

Do you think that Heiken ashi only can be selected as Take Profit when added by new conditions block?

Wouldn't it be easiest to just select it by TP in Buy/Sell Block.
I still dont get it why it doesnt react even to added Candle ID 1.

Hey guys,

currently testing different approaches for a trend following system.

Do somebody has found a good approaches for a indicator to avoid sideways or choppy market conditions.

Just talking about a filtering system for entry conditions.

For trade mgnt and exit conditions currently testing different approaches as well, but just talking about entry.

Main idea is based on 2-3 EMAs.

above the 200 for long trend

and 20 and 10 for mid and short term trend.

For buy, price must be above 200 and the 20 and 10 must align as well below.

My second condition is MACD with 6, 12, 1 settings, trigger is the 0 line cross.

For Sell vise versa.

When market momentum increases the EMAs expend and fan out.
When sideways market crosses EMAs from below and above and EMA Line for 10 and 20 mostly move flat.

Have testet both the breakout through the 10 and 20 EMA and also the Pullback if market has broken the EMA before and then bounces/ retests back.
Havent found a setting in FX dreema to tell for EMAs Line angle 0 ° also dont find this approach good because Moving Average still is lagging indicator.

What i've tested is ATR and ADX indicator to use for momentum indication above certain level, but what i've found is that ATR still increases in sideways conditions, even above certain minimal level

and ADX tends to be legging even more.
Even though if is above 20 or 25 level, market often tends to range as well, if ADX shows that market seems to be trending.

For the MACD i've found that when market moves tight or ranging, that signal lines often moves parallel to the 0 level and doesnt give clear momentum shift.

Thanks to everybody helping out.

@l-andorrà

Forgot ask,

so if condition block closes trade either by Heiken Ashi or trailing Stop

i need to select "no Take Profit" under the Buy/Sell Block as well right?

@l-andorrà

Hi thank you very much for your help.

So if i get you right, this section need to placed next to actual entry conditions block right?

Do you have to connect the " For each trade" row

and the "pass" row with the actual entry section on the left?

So after a trade was entered by Buy/ Sell Market Block, do you have to connect it as well or can it be simply added without connection like in your example?

@l-andorrà

Thank you. If i got you correct the trailing stop should be seperate next to the main signals?
But how does it differentiate between the main exit signal and the trailing Stop as backup exit?

I would like to make that trade is either close by Heiken Ashi or the trailing stop.
Like a Close by Heiken Candle or if not by ATR trailing stop.

The idea is that Heiken Ashi stays quite consistent when trending and color rarely changes.

The Trailing Stop would be the emergency "safety net" if Momentum Candle would switch direction so quick that Heiken Ashi Color has not yet changed but price has dropped way back and therefore Take Profit would still be quite good.

What have noticed from backtesting, it doesnt help to trail Stop to break even as "safety", because often market tends to come back to entry level before moving in trend direction.
Also tested trailing stop based on fixed pip parameter would restrict market as well to early.

Heiken Ashi could be the "main" exit signal but trailing also Trailing Stop would be the backup if Heiken Ashi still hasent changed signal.

Often noticed, that when there is huge Momentum Candle, often Price retraces faster in previous direction again.
But most of the times Heiken Ashi would stay very stable and candles would rise normally.

@ambrogio

Sorry but this isnt helpful, because that is the main purpose of using Heiken Ashi for this strategy.

When trade is open that the EA dont close trade way to early.

Backtested it a lot, that fixed Pips Take Profit is way to strict and every trade is unique for stop loss level as well, therefore chose the SL based on Balance in % of *2 ATR,
but otherwise isnt good to always make it Take Profit based on ATR multiplier for instance, because often Take Profit isnt reached, and Heiken Ashi would indicate perfect exit signal which great profit for each individual trade.
Some Trades take longer and some would be better to be closed earlier if momentum changes.

When using other indicators as Take Profit, Bollinger Bands for instance this would reduce profitable trades way to early when successful.

Also noticed that simple trailing stop based on indicator would also be to strict, cause market fluctuation is normal and trade would be close to earlier, Heiken Ashi would stay most of the times in trend color and market has good room to expend.

Found that Heiken Ashi is perfect Trade Mgnt/ Exit indicator.

@l-andorrà

Ok got it, but do have a solution for heiken ashi Take Profit please?

What i dont get is, that is works perfectly as condition block to open position,

but same indication as take profit doesnt work, even though is is available as option to make it use in chart indicators as take profit, like others like parabolic sar,
would work as well.

I've double checked, dont should be used as custom price fraction indicator like ATR, MACD... better custom price level.
Checked for both open and close price from HA and also with or without Candle ID 1.

@l-andorrà

Ok i understand, thank you

@ambrogio

Do you mean i would make it like on the pic to add a " If position" side where it can be close by heiken ashi?

@ambrogio

Hi,

So you mean that even if would change Change Id to variable and would use this instead Heiken Ashi still would be working correct as Take Profit?

I heard from other people that you should use Candle ID 1 for Heiken Ashi cause it is an average indicator and if you would make it to get signal from open this didnt work for me either.

What i dont still get tho is, why can you use Heiken Ashi either as condition or indicator is visible block and it works, but it is available in Take Profit but doesnt work.

Yes but with opposite i thought cause there is Heiken Ashi already added to chart.
That for buy trade it would look for opposite candle to close and vise versa.

Ok got that with the arrow, but probably when trade is closed this would be enough i think, but good idea anyway.

@l-andorrà

Have already delete 1 thread from before sir.

Cause there is coming new threads everyday older posts already have been disguised, really dont want to spam, if there are 10 new threads everyday, how should somebody read this please. Nobody looking to older posts, wouldn't do it either.

Just looking for an answer to the question why Heiken Ashio doesnt work by Take Profit in Buy/ Sell Block and yes got 1-2 answers but not directly to this question.

Hello everybody, @fxDreema,

Could somebody please explain,

why is there an option to take Profit in Buy sell Block by indicator but this doesnt close position when testing?

Easiest way would be for a buy position to close it indicator.
Already tested it by Heiken Ashi, Parabolic... and some more.

Tried with "Custom price level" for the indicator but this doesnt help.

For Stop Loss it works perfectly fine with external indicator " Custom price fraction" which isnt directly on the chart but below, like ATR for instance.

Has somebody an idea why there is this option anyway if it doesnt work this way?

Thank
https://fxdreema.com/shared/sb4V5aZFc

Hi everybody, @fxDreema

trying to build an EA, if trade was successfully opened that it closes either by Heiken Ashi Candle or by ATR *1,5 or *2 Mulitplier Trailing Stop.

Please ignore entry condition this would be just placeholder only looking for a solution from Block Buy/ Sell once Trade is opened.

For HA i currently dont use it for Entry conditions only looking for Trade Management e.g. for Buy Trade if Bearish Candle 1 Closes and Sell Bullish Candle 1 closes.

For ATR SL would like to give it enough space for market to breath, dont wont it to trailing to Break even only ATR 14 Range Multiplier.

When testing in Buy/Sell Block ATR 14 with *2 to place Stop works perfectly fine.

Question is which version in need to use:

1.)Do i need " If position" statement block additionally to opening condition side,

2.) Do i need " If position" + " Or" statement to either close it by Condition or Trailing Stop

3.) or can i just make it on instance below the Buy/ Sell Block?

This would be 1 example.

https://fxdreema.com/shared/pugWuIrXc

Thx

What i also noticed, why did you add condition to draw arrow, it this necessary for closing the trade in the EA?