Posts made by fifeivkbdedwcf

@ambrogio

Hi thank you for post.

Changed the idea to use Heiken Ashi for Entry as well recently.
Therefore would like to only use it for Trade Mgnt to close when for long position the opposite appears and short vise versa.

Do add those condition blocks as seperate "if trade" statement or do you add them for Buy and Sell conditions just below entry condition blocks?

Moreover in Buy Sell Block you would the leave Take Profit for Non right?

Just asking for curiosity why is there an option in Buy Sell block to close position by indicator like Heiken Ashi with " Custom Price Level" by this doesnt help with closing position?

@l-andorrà

Could you please tell me why i simply cant apply this directly from the buy sell take profit section?

Tried it with different settings, but trades doesnt close by heiken ashi.
Why is there a option to selected Take Profit by indicator/ in chart, Custom price level, when it doesnt work that way?
Just asking cause you seem more advanced in this whole coding game.

@Edtoloza

Just wondering why there is a option for Heiken Ashi Indicator for Take Profit section in Buy/ Sell Blocks.
Tried it with different settings, but trade doesnt close by the oppsoite candle.

For instance if trade is a buy/ Bull, it would be easiest that in Take Profit i can select Bear candle 1 close and previous oppsite, like on the screenshot.

Why is there a option if it doesnt work that way, thought you might probably know, cause it seems you more advanced than me.

Hi, do i need for second block structure a if statement as well?

Is this like you suggested?

Did replace the idea for trailing stop for now, dont know if it might be really that useful.

https://fxdreema.com/shared/LDczeeRrb

@jstap

Yes, like mentioned tested it today afternoon.

When switching the x> to just > in the Di conditions block it opens 1 trade like desired.

Was it this what you meant by change the logic?

As i was told, for ADX indicator it should be "crosses" for the +Di and -Di not only above but oddly then there is the double trade placed with x>.

This was the test when it opned only 1 position with the is > function.

https://fxdreema.com/forum/assets/uploads/files/1695909508743-mt5-testing.png

@Edtoloza

Yeah,got that, but how about the first approach like on the latest photo.
This is how i started to apply this.
Directly with the Take Profit as Heiken Ashi opposite candle.
Then you're right the close trade block isnt necessary.

Unfortuntely it doesnt work with Take Profit in the Buy/ Sell Block, like mentioned even though Heiken Ashi is available as option.

Do you know why or how to fix it?

Thx

@ose

Left upper corner.

@Edtoloza

Can you please tell me why first approach doesnt work, if under Take Profit section, cause its an in chart indicator, and Heiken Ashi is available, that it doesnt work simply this way, you know to have fewer blocks.

@Edtoloza

Hi thx for your quick reply.

So if i got you correct, left column is for detecting Trade condition and right one is for "management" with Heiken Ashi right?

I was no sure how to apply this, that i uses Heiken Ashi also as the Take Profit.
Therefore got the tip from somebody else to add block for Close Trades for opposite.

Currently testing different approaches, thinking about ADX Di crosses for entry condition instead of Heiken Ashi Candle above Candle 2 and Candle of Heiken Ashi to switch from Opposite to trigger candle.

Like previous was Bear and current is Bull, Candle 1. for example.

This was my latest project:

https://fxdreema.com/shared/70vJITJjb

Please note switched to MT5 currently.
But MQL5 blocks seem to be fairly identical to MT4 in FX Dreema.

@jstap

Ok, with logic you mean the input inself like Di mode +Di -Di?
Yes, but isnt it like that?
You know, cause it needs to be that +Di crosses for buy and -Di crosses for short.
As i got it this ADX is non directional therefore for both it should be Di > than other Di. Or X> if crosses then works.
Otherwise i'm not sure how you mean this.

@jstap

Did a quick test only with <> for ADX DI conditions now the EA places only 1 position per bar.
Did you mean that that <x , >x caused the missleading output?

@jstap

Ok, but how can i prevent this?
I thought therefore there are a block for Buy and a block for Sell conditions, because the Crossover for DI+ to -DI is the opposite right?

For Buy Di+ should cross -DI from below
and for Sell -Di should cross +Di from below.
You know, cause ADX is non directional.

When testing conditions blocks for Heiken Ashi i havent had this before as well.

https://fxdreema.com/shared/KhDjgTe1e

Here's an example project in MT4.

As someone suggested MT4 isnt that different than MT5 in FX dreema.

Hi guys,

i tried to build an EA for Heiken Ashi.
Would like to close trade when opposite signal for HA candles appear.
Currently testing different approaches as well.

Under Buy/ Sell Block under Take Profit, cause its an in chart indicator tried with " Custom Price Level" with indicator of Heiken Ashi and chose the opposite type.

Stop Loss is calculated for ATR Multiplier for external Chart indicator which works perfectly fine. Dont know why Heiken Ashi isnt working.

When testing in Metatrader, when trades run in profit it isnt closed.

Also tried with Close Block below with Sell/ Buy Signal, but didnt seem to work as well.

https://fxdreema.com/shared/SBCeeNgwe

Tested it in MT5 with Close Trade Block below.

Unfortunately still doesnt close trade on opposite candle.

@jstap

How do you mean? So as you have explained i added once per bar below the last condition block, right?
The other condition is for ADX for Trend strengh additonally to ADX Di+ and Di-.
Tested it with and without this condition, buy and sell are still opened like before.
Testing different approaches currently for ADX.

@jstap

Hi, thank you. so i would make it Check for no position-> Condition-> Once per bar for both sides each, or can i use 1 block for once per bar below conditions for both?
Is this problem only for ADX indicator?
When using Heiken Ashi for instance it didnt appear as well for both at same time.
Just asking.

https://fxdreema.com/shared/oOQQUhu4

Just checked with the new adjustments, but problem still remains same

Hey guys, @fxDreema

switched from Mt4 to Mt5.
Before never had the issue that both buy and sell were opened even when there is once per bar block.

Tried both with 1 block for once per bar and for each buy and sell row both doesnt seem to help.

any ideas, tips?

Thx

https://fxdreema.com/shared/R3yv26bdd

Tested it in MT5.
Please note its without the trailing stop block.
Unfortunately still doesnt close trade on opposite candle

Please note also switched to MT5 might be the same then right?
One more question, can i also add 1 Block in general for both Buy/ Sell conditions, when they are the same, like a trailing Stop for instance, when i would link it below for both Buy and Sell?

https://fxdreema.com/shared/MZFyOxEre

@fifeivkbdedwcf

Hi @l-andorrà

Thx for your reply.

So under the Buy/ Sell Block you would select non for Take Profit and only add the Close Trade Block like you suggested?